海角社区

Degree Defense

Essays on Science Evaluation

PhD defence Guangyao Zhang.

Time
- Europe/Amsterdam
Address
https://www.youtube.com/@UMphddefense

This PhD thesis explores various aspects of science evaluation, with a focus on the peer review process. Peer review is a critical mechanism for maintaining the quality of scientific research, but little is known about how it actually operates. The research examines factors influencing paper selection, the duration of peer review, and the role of reviewer comments. The key findings indicate that while paper quality plays a significant role in the peer review process, author reputation is important for junior researchers. Additionally, papers that attract more attention tend to go through peer review faster, and reviewers are more likely to praise authors with whom they share cultural similarities. The study also addresses the growing demand for digital skills in the scientific workforce, analyzing job advertisements to highlight trends in digital competencies such as data analysis and programming. Overall, the thesis provides insights into peer review behavior and the impact of digitalization on the scientific community.

Related content

News

Finding Order in the Chaos: 3D Bioprinting for Functional Artificial Tissues

Fellow Sofia Salazar is learning to produce microlayered tissue to advance sustainability and medical sciences, fostering academic collaboration.

19 Dec 2025

News

Understanding How Bacteria Organize and Build their "Super-Cities" and Finding Ways to Neutralize Them

Bacteria have long harnessed the power of many, and if we are to control them, we must understand their coordinated protection strategies.

09 Dec 2025

News

Webinar: Biotechnology as an Essential Tool for Circular Economy and Development

UBA and ITAPROQ launch a webinar series on biotech tools to boost circular economy, linking academic research with sustainable industry practices.

03 Dec 2025